The family of a father who was tragically murdered by a recently released prisoner is taking legal action against the Scottish government, claiming that the authorities are not taking responsibility for their actions. Stuart Quinn, a violent criminal with a history of psychotic episodes, brutally stabbed Alan Geddes 40 times in Aberdeen shortly after being released from prison in 2019. Quinn is now serving a minimum of 18 years behind bars after admitting to the murder.
An official report revealed that the killer’s unplanned release was mishandled by prison, council, and health officials, as there was no support package or accommodation provided, which likely contributed to the outcome. Quinn, who was upset and crying upon his release, was supposed to receive help for personal issues. The Mental Welfare Commission reported that if Quinn’s mental health care had been properly addressed in the years leading up to the fatal attack, the risks could have been mitigated.
Alan Geddes, who met his killer at a pub and offered him a place to stay, died a Good Samaritan. His sister Sandra Geddes has been fighting for justice since the tragic incident. The system to prepare inmates for release and reintegration into society was suspended just three months before Quinn was released due to operational pressures, leading to inconsistencies and gaps in handling inmates.
Sandra Geddes expressed her disappointment and frustration, feeling that there is something being concealed from her. She believes that taking legal action is her only option to uncover the truth and hold those responsible accountable. She emphasized the lack of transparency and openness in how the authorities have communicated with her, leading her to seek answers through the court.
While the Scottish Prison Service and the Scottish government declined to comment due to the ongoing legal proceedings, Scottish Conservative MSP Douglas Lumsden supported the Geddes family’s decision to pursue legal action. He criticized the SNP for failing Alan Geddes and his family at every turn, showing understanding for their choice to take civil action against the government.
Aberdeen City Council chose not to provide a statement, but NHS Grampian confirmed that legal action has been initiated against them. The case is being handled by the NHS Scotland Central Legal Office. The family’s pursuit of justice sheds light on the need for accountability and transparency in how the authorities handle such critical situations to prevent similar tragedies in the future.
