Former Twitter Employee Awarded $600k in Lawsuit Over Alleged Dismissal for Ignoring Elon Musk’s 2022 Email
A former Twitter employee has made headlines after winning a significant settlement in a lawsuit against the company for his alleged wrongful termination. Gary Rooney, who was based at Twitter’s European headquarters in Dublin, was awarded a 550,000 euro settlement, equivalent to approximately $600,000, after being dismissed for failing to comply with Elon Musk’s demand for an “extremely hardcore” work culture.
The Guardian reported that Rooney informed Ireland’s Workplace Relations Commission that he did not affirmatively respond to Musk’s infamous email in November 2022. The email, sent less than a month after Musk completed his $44 billion platform acquisition, requested employees’ commitment to a grueling work pace to develop “the new Twitter” or face resignation.
Musk’s email outlined the expectations for employees to work long hours at high intensity, with only exceptional performance being deemed acceptable. Employees were required to click “yes” on a provided link to signify their commitment to the new vision of Twitter. Failure to do so within 24 hours would result in a severance package equivalent to three months’ salary.
Rooney’s Testimony and Controversial Dismissal
Rooney testified during a five-day hearing at the Workplace Relations Commission in Dublin that he initially adored his job before Musk acquired Twitter. When he received the “Fork in the Road” email, Rooney expressed disbelief and fear, suspecting it might be spam or malware. He confided in a colleague through the company’s internal messaging system, expressing his concerns about the changes happening within the company.
In his messages, Rooney predicted that “Twitter 2.0 won’t be for you and me,” indicating his apprehension about the direction the company was taking under Musk’s leadership. Despite his reluctance to click “yes” on the email, Rooney maintained that he did not resign from his position at Twitter.
The Workplace Relations Commission adjudicator ruled in Rooney’s favor, stating that the 24-hour notice period given by Musk was insufficient and not a reasonable notice period for such a significant decision. The adjudicator also dismissed Rooney’s concerns about Musk’s takeover as irrelevant to the termination of his employment.
Rooney’s unfair dismissal award of $60,000, a record in Ireland, includes compensation for his lost remuneration from January 2023 to May 2024 and estimated lost future earnings. His solicitor, Barry Kenny, welcomed the decision, emphasizing the gravity of the case and the importance of treating employees fairly in the workplace.
Implications for Musk’s Leadership Style
This isn’t the first time Elon Musk has faced criticism for his controversial approach to employee management. Last year, former Twitter executive Esther Crawford was terminated under contentious circumstances after gaining attention for sleeping on the office floor to meet deadlines.
Crawford later spoke out against Musk’s leadership style in a video, highlighting his perceived lack of empathy and heavy reliance on intuition. The termination of Rooney and Crawford, along with Rooney’s substantial unfair dismissal award, have once again brought Musk’s leadership practices into question.
It remains to be seen whether Rooney’s significant win will prompt Musk to reconsider his approach to employee terminations and workplace culture at Twitter, now rebranded as X. Musk’s history of headline-grabbing terminations and the recent legal victory for Rooney have shed light on the company’s employment practices and the impact they have on employees.
Potential Impact on Twitter’s Workforce
As Twitter continues to navigate its transition under Musk’s leadership, the fallout from Rooney’s case could have lasting implications for the company’s workforce. The divide among employees who embraced the “Twitter 2.0” vision and those who opted to leave due to negative sentiments reflects the challenges of implementing significant changes within an organization.
Lauren Wegman, Twitter’s Senior Director of People Analytics, testified during the hearing that Musk’s “Fork in the Road” email resulted in a mass exodus of employees. Of the 270 recipients of the email, 235 chose to leave the company, while the remaining 35 employees who did not accept the offer had their resignations accepted.
Wegman described a workforce that was split between those willing to embrace the new direction set by Musk and those who felt compelled to leave due to the demanding work culture. The departure of a significant number of employees following the email underscores the impact of leadership decisions on employee morale and retention.
Lessons Learned and Future Considerations
Rooney’s case serves as a cautionary tale for companies and leaders about the importance of clear communication, fair treatment of employees, and the implications of abrupt changes in the workplace. The ruling in his favor highlights the need for organizations to consider the impact of their actions on employees and ensure that decisions are made with transparency and fairness.
As Musk and Twitter move forward, the outcome of Rooney’s lawsuit may prompt a reevaluation of management practices and employee relations within the company. The record-breaking unfair dismissal award underscores the seriousness of the case and the need for companies to prioritize a supportive and inclusive work environment for their employees.
In conclusion, the legal victory for Gary Rooney against Twitter and Elon Musk serves as a reminder of the importance of fair treatment and respect for employees in the workplace. The case raises questions about leadership practices, employee relations, and the impact of drastic changes on workforce morale. As companies strive to navigate challenges and transitions, the lessons learned from Rooney’s case can guide future decision-making and foster a culture of accountability and respect in the workplace.
This article was rewritten by [Your Name] for [Your News Site].
